A Study on Conflicts confronted by Indian Muslim Women: Revocation of the Triple Talaq bill

By Janhavi Bhavsar, (Law student, Government Law College, Indore)


Today, divorce is the largest aspect of Muslim Matrimonial Law and now it’s been more than a year since the triple talaq exercise became against the law. The present article specializes in the real conflicts being confronted by Indian Muslim women earlier than and after the revocation of the triple talaq bill. Revocation of the bill turned into an exceptional victory for the Indian Muslim women however no person ever will observe the effects on the way to come, even after the exercise has become a crime. What if the husband or her in-laws or maybe the society will now no longer accept her after his punishment duration is over or maybe earlier than that. There is still a long battle to be confronted by the women even after criminalizing this exercise.

Triple Talaq and Triple Talaq Bill

Understanding the idea of Triple Talaq, In Muslim Law divorce is positioned within side the class of permissible things, yet this despicable aspect has existed in abundance. In the class of unilateral divorce, there's one idea known as Talaq-ul-bidaat which incorporates triple talaq, wherein a Muslim husband can really utter the word talaq 3 times to her spouse will dissolve the marriage and this form of divorce is irrevocable.[i]

The exercise of triple talaq changed into shifting out of palms and the regulation to make triple talaq unconstitutional was pending to be carried out in Rajya Sabha for such a long time. Another reality Islam does not keep the triple talaq exercise as lawful as well. In the Landmark case of Shayara Bano vs. Union of India[ii], Shayara Bano challenged Triple Talaq, Polygamy, and Nikaah Halala as those practices violate Article 14, 15, 21, and 25 of the Constitution. On 22nd August 2017, the Supreme Court gave the judgment within side the majority of 3:2 and held the exercise of Triple Talaq as Unconstitutional i.e. Void and Illegal. The Triple Talaq bill is also acknowledged as The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Ordinance, 2019 was repealed on 31st July 2019 whilst the bill was passed by each house of the legislature. The bill says that this exercise is void and unlawful and endorsed the women to experience their essential rights.


Conflicts Prior revocation of the bill

One can’t experience what precisely Indian Muslim women have been going through simply by imagining years of her marital life may be ended simply by uttering 3 words actually at any time, any movement, or any place. Even they were typing talaq 3 times electronically. Muslim man used to release their anger on their other halves, they act on their whims, they used to utter this phrase really even if the salt or spice is over or not enough, and for that, they used to sprinkle triple talaq and dissolve their marriage for that mild mistake.

This conflict was going an extended way since 1986 while absolutely each person such as the family, community, society, or even authorities crushed the lone voice of Shah Bano[iii]. Then after, in approximately 2009-2010, women commenced raising voice collectively and were standing collectively demanding for the change. Many NGOs and different bodies or even the people of different religions were helping them for justice.

India is the 3rd biggest Muslim community with 90 Million Muslim women who have been going through the danger of unexpected, oral, and out of court divorce. According to the census of 2011 data, 13.5% out of all married women were under 15 years of age and 49% between 14 to 19 years of age. Marriage at such an early age in maximum cases decreases the opportunity of obtaining adulthood, education, or maybe being financially sound. A survey by Bharatiya Mahila Andolan discovered that 95% of divorced women acquire no maintenance.[iv] How even they can keep themselves and their kids.


Conflicts Post revocation of the bill

A lady from Uttar Pradesh stated in an interview “I feel at peace as parliament passed this bill and made triple talaq unlawful, it was turning into a sport for them, wherein the danger lay in regular conversations”. She additionally delivered “When a man offers talaq, our blood boils and we feel like a soul chickening out from our body. But how could men ever recognize this factor?” We can simply consider by her phrases that what a top-notch victory it was for them.

But the primary question bobbing up right here is what criminalizing triple talaq will preserve in women’s life? This Bill certainly hailed as an extremely good victory for gender justice in Indian records and plenty of have given a reprieve to Muslim women from the possibility of an unexpected abandonment of marriage. However, it nonetheless left the destiny of numerous women uncertain. As if a Muslim lady sends her husband to jail, will ever the husband accept her spouse after the completion of the punishment, or maybe her in-laws or the society will accept her? There remains a big question mark right here. The bill did not assure the safety of women and their kids and additionally no guarantee of reconciliation together along with her husband with any proper terms. We can see the surveys introduced above which says maximum women don’t even gain their adulthood duration or can’t complete their education. Hitting the truth no one will ever deal with her properly or even later if they take mutual divorce or judicial divorce she becomes a burden on her very own mother and father due to the fact in maximum cases they are not financially capable of keeping herself or her children. They simplest need to cease this exercise not to make it a crime. But the factor is if they don’t make it a crime no man will ever take this seriously they keep threatening their wives with this power, although it doesn’t have any protection after that however a man will think two times earlier than uttering this phrase.

Opening some other Chapter, Some intellects have been additionally debating that this is a personal law and is civil in nature and has not anything to do with criminal matters as the parliament made it a crime. They are concluding that this bill isn't a pro-woman however anti-minority bill because it's far triggering the Muslim Personal Law. They brought that we're witnessing criminal provisions in the matter of marriage and divorce.[v] Muslims are no minority in India, around 172 Million Muslims dwelling in India with dignity and due respect. Secondly; the bill is absolutely in the favor of Muslim women as this practice really violates the essential rights given to them.


Conclusion

Alongside the prevailing bill is shielding the consideration of the Muslim women in the country and ensuring them their fundamental rights. The bill is focusing on making them feel secure, safe, and assured because they're a massive segment of the society that can’t be kept discriminated, denied, and deprived. If the country and the humans dwelling in the country who honestly desires to progress, they should make up their thoughts and remember the pros of the bill that is protecting the rights given to women. But at equal time, the reality can’t be hidden that the bill doesn’t deliver any protection to the women and her children and this factor can cause a large effect in the coming years.

[i] Dr. Paras Diwan & Peeyushi Diwan, Muslim Law in modern India 81(2017). [ii] Shayara bano vs. Union of India(2017) 9 SCC1 (Supreme Court of India). [iii] Shah Bano case, 1985(1) SCALE 767 ,1985 (3) SCR 844 , 1985(2) SCC 556 , AIR 1985 SC 945, High Court of M.P. Indore bench. [iv]Triple talaq: How it affects lives of India's 90 million Muslim women”, https://www.indiatoday.in/fyi/story/triple-talaq-muslim-women-supreme-court-sharia-law-islam-968630-2017-03-30, August 22, 2017 [v]“Triple talaq billis a ‘a complete charade’ against minorities, say civil society members ”, https://scroll.in/latest/932325/triple-talaq-bill-is-a-complete-charade-and-against-minorities-say-civil-society-members, 31 July, 2019.

89 views0 comments